Episode 184 - “No One Came”- A Poem I Wrote About Leaving Mormonism

What happens when leaving the religion you were raised in also means losing the friendships and community you've spent years building? In the Mormon church, stories about those who leave are often used to maintain group cohesion and discourage members from questioning the church. But when your values no longer align with the institution you've long been part of, you may have to make a difficult choice. In this episode, Sara shares her deeply personal experience of leaving Mormonism and how that decision impacted her life and relationships. You’ll hear the letter she wrote to her friends when she finally left the church, along with the poem she later wrote for The Book of Once-Mormon Women about the pain of loss and her longing to reconnect.

How long have you been putting off the hard conversation? Join Sara live for one hour for her free workshop, SPEAK UP. There’s no replay, so bring the conversation you keep avoiding. You’ll learn the Three Speak Up Skills and figure out what’s keeping you stuck.

Here’s what you’ll uncover in this episode:

  • Why people who leave the Mormon church are portrayed as weak or untrustworthy

  • How stories of people leaving religious structures are used to discourage open conversations about faith

  • What led Sara to leave the church and how she explained her decision to the people in her life

  • The grief behind the poem Sara wrote about the friends who never reached out after she left

  • The scripture Sara wrote reflecting her belief in her own voice and heart as divine guidance

Register for SPEAK UP: sarafisk.coach/voice

Find Sara here:

sarafisk.coach

instagram.com/sarafiskcoach

facebook.com/SaraFiskCoaching

tiktok.com/@sarafiskcoach

youtube.com/@sarafiskcoaching1333

Transcript


00:59

I wanna share something deeply personal for this episode, and it requires, I think, a little bit of context to be understood. Mormonism, like any other insular group, creates stories around people who leave to keep members inside the confines of the group's rules. And while these stories might sometimes be based in a fact or two, they are often untrue. But a story doesn't need to be true to be effective, so stories are told about people who leave Mormonism, why they leave, and who they become. They leave because they want to sin. They leave because they were offended by someone, which always means in a prideful or stubborn way, or they left because they didn't nurture their faith enough, and the implication there is that they're weak. And people who leave become vengeful, and are dangerous, and want to hurt or destroy God's kingdom, so they should not be trusted. People who leave are weak-willed and easily captivated by the, quote, unquote, "ideas of the world," and they should not be trusted. People who leave have lost the Spirit and can't tell right from wrong anymore and should not be trusted. There was also really specific teaching about people who left. They were supposed to leave the church and then leave the church alone, not criticize it, not talk about any of the bad things that happened, not say anything negative about it at all. I grew up with these stories and have heard them repeated from church leaders all the way from the top, like the president of the church, all the way down to the local level. And members learn to watch each other for signs that one is, quote, unquote, "faithful," and to make judgments based on whether or not your behavior is faithful enough. One of the most painful consequences is that if you are having sincere questions about faith, if there are things that you don't agree with and wanna talk about, you can't talk to just anyone, and there's almost automatic suspicion that clouds every conversation. And often, when you most need to be held by your community and you take these questions to church leaders or friends, they engage with you as if you are the problem instead of being able to give the questions or issues the attention that they deserve. 


 03:39

It is really painful in church congregations. It's even more painful in families, and it's often catastrophic in friend groups. I had had a personal experience where I knew that what Mormonism taught about being gay, that it was a choice and a sin, was wrong, and I had watched what happens to gay members of the church as they struggled to stay active in the faith under such a heavy burden that often made the people in their congregations not just indifferent to them, but hostile toward them. If they came out, they were shoved to the margins of their communities. Policies were enacted church-wide to prevent them from being able to hold positions of service, to have their children baptized, or to even date. They were threatened not just with the loss of their families, but there was no path for them to get into Mormon heaven, and so it's no wonder that many of them just didn't want to live anymore.Eventually, the church stopped teaching that queer people were choosing to be queer, but they also didn't specify that there was really only one other choice, that God had created them that way, and it left this group of vulnerable people in, like, a permanent spiritual limbo, and that was the atmosphere when my daughter came out when she was 15. I had been homeschooling her along with my other kids for about 10 years at that point, and we had been part of a wonderful group of about 10 Mormon homeschooling families. We planned classes together. We taught our kids together. We went on field trips together. We had book clubs, and potlucks, and celebrations. We cared for each other's children like our own and had become very close over that period of time. And when my husband started to leave the church and stopped wearing his garments, which is the white Mormon T-shirt and knee-length underwear that are symbolic of living a faithful Mormon life, it wasn't too long before one of my closest friends said, "I notice Dan isn't wearing his garments anymore. What's going on?" I was terrified because I knew that Dan was having a lot of questions, a lot of issues with the church, and that he might be on his way out of the church. And I knew that that meant that not only would he become the subject of all the stories about people who leave, but that I would also be suspect. Within a very short period of time, another friend asked to meet me and literally sat me down to interview me about whether or not I was still a faithful, believing Mormon, asking me very specific, very invasive questions about aspects of my faith like a church leader would do in one of the famous Mormon worthiness interviews. But what she told me was that she would not let me teach her children unless I could answer her questions to her satisfaction. The truth at that point was that I had a lot of questions, but I was also just trying to hold everything together while my world was falling apart. My husband, who I loved, was leaving, and I didn't yet know what that meant for us. A lot of people got divorced over things like this. 


 07:10

We were determined to try and hang on to each other, but I still didn't know what was gonna happen. I didn't know what it meant for my family. I had hidden his process from everyone. I was scared of their judgment. I had lived by that time with deep fear for several years, and now it was coming to the group of friends who had felt like family. When I did finally leave, I wrote all of them a letter.I knew that our friendship would end, but I had hoped that it wouldn't. This was the letter that I wrote them. "Dear friends, I write to you with all the love and gratitude I've ever felt for you, for our little group of mamas who've educated their kids together, who were there for each other in sorrow and sunshine and everything in between. I write because of my love and respect for you. You have all been witness to the last decade of my life and borne me through many tears and trials. I love you all as I have loved my own family. And because I love and so deeply respect each of you, I want you to hear this from me directly. I've made the decision not to return to church for the time being. Chief among my concerns is how the church currently teaches about LGBTQ children of God. Rachel is queer. I have nieces and nephews who are also queer, and there is no place for them in the gospel. The shame and self-disgust that most LGBTQ youth feel in the church is something I choose not to be a part of. I desperately hope that continuing revelation reveals a place for them to participate completely in the gospel. I've imagined how you might each react to hearing this, and I understand your possible sadness and confusion. I get it. I've felt it all, too. I realize that you might have suspicion or worry or even fear or anger, and I get that, too. I've made this decision the same way I've made all of the other decisions of great import in my life: to serve a mission, to marry Dan, to homeschool after a long labor and struggle to understand the mind and will of God for me. There's more to the story, but suffice it to say, I've labored with this intensely for almost five years, and it has been the most excruciating, heartbreaking thing I've ever done. I feel deep peace about this decision. I don't expect that you will agree, and that's okay. But I do hope that you've had enough experience with me to know how seriously I would take this. I am not having a faith crisis. My faith in God is intact and strong. I'm having a religious institution crisis, and for now I need to leave. I hope this won't affect our relationship. I hope it won't affect your relationship with my children. I have no interest in converting anyone to my way of thinking. It's a painful road, and it's not my place. I hope to always know what is going on in your lives and in your children's lives. I love them very much and want to celebrate them with you. I hope you will include me. If you have questions, I'm happy to answer them as best I can. I love each of you so much, and I'm grateful for how you've blessed my life." It's weird to, to read that letter now and see how much I was trying to make them understand and how desperately I, I hoped that they would. 


 10:31

Years later, I was asked to contribute an essay to a book of experience about women leaving the church. I tried to write an essay, but what came out instead was this poem about this group of friends and my grief at losing them. This is from The Book of Once Mormon Women, edited by Katie Stringham and Sue Johnson, and it contains essays and writings of 30 different women, and mine is one. It's called No One Came. The thing that was the most surprising, bewildering, confusing, unbelievable, devastating, and telling was that no one came. Not one person in the days and weeks after I sent you the letter said I was leaving, bared my heart and my reasons. No one came. Not during those first weeks when I would wake on Sundays disoriented and wearing sadness instead of my church dress. Not in the months after I learned that I could look at the chapel without crying every time I drove by. Not in the months or years since then. Not to my door, not in my phone, not in my texts, not in my mailbox, not in my DMs. No one came.It was so strange, so heartbreaking. Just silence. I tried to slip out softly, an exodus that wouldn't shake the walls, leaving the church and leaving it alone so maybe you'd see I wasn't a threat, wasn't something you could catch, so that maybe the thread between us wouldn't snap. Did I imagine the thread? Didn't we tie it around each other, weaving it back and forth between us week after week, month after month, year after year? Do you remember how I held you when you lost your baby? How I brought lasagna to your door when your son was bullied? How I packed your whole kitchen in bubble wrap, every fragile thing wrapped as tight as our bond? Do you remember how you bathed me after my surgery? How you picked me up when I ran out of gas? How you drove me to the doctor's office through all those appointments and took notes because I was too sick to pay attention? Do you remember how I always made hummus for book club because it was your favorite? How I came over after the storm to gather up broken tree limbs? How I wrapped the tulle around the basketball hoops for your daughter's wedding and stayed long enough to take it all down? How you celebrated my birthdays, brought me chocolate from Switzerland, arranged your schedule to watch my kids like they were yours? The meetings we sat through, the confidences we shared, the stories we know about each other. I thought we were bound together with thousands of stitches of the thickest thread. Prayers and potlucks, baptisms and book clubs, a patchwork that could not fray.But you didn't come. You didn't come to ask me what it was like to walk for years on ground that felt like it was moving under my feet as faith was shifting and giving way. You didn't come to ask me how it felt to watch the things that I thought would last forever just slip through my fingers. Some days my faith fell like leaves from a tree, softly swirling noiselessly to the ground. Other days it fell like earthquakes that made the land heave and slide into unrecognizable terrain. 


 14:19

I don't blame you for not noticing. I hid it from you as long as I could. I didn't know what you would say, but I never dreamed it would be nothing. As the seams of my faith ripped apart, I guess the seams of us did too. I wish I could weave us back together. I miss the warmth of being tight and stitched together. But we feel threadbare. You never came to check on me, to ask me how I was, to ask me what happened, to extend to me the tiny kindness of listening to my broken faith and broken heart.Sometimes when the memories come, I turn them over and over again, piecing together scraps, trying to make sense of what we had and what we lost. My breath catches and the tears gather and spill over, carrying the weight of our past with the present that still shocks me down my cheeks. And my heart swells with the peculiar mix of grief and astonishment. Will it ever go away? Will it ever not hurt? I don't know, but today it does. I was also asked to contribute a scripture, and it was something that was supposed to represent my current belief, and you can hear in it how much I changed over time. Here's what I wrote. And it shall come to pass in that day that she shall hear her own voice as if it were scripture, and she shall believe it. She shall hearken unto her own voice as the voice of God, and she shall follow it. And she shall trust her own heart as good, and she shall walk upon it as her divine path, and she shall never be lost.


Next
Next

Episode 183 - Blue Tsumani, Now What? Falling in Love with the Future with Celeste Davis